Enforcement
CNIL fines Fnac Darty 7 million euros over mobile app tracking
The French data protection authority fined Fnac Darty for using mobile app trackers without consent to train algorithms and display recommendations.
The French Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés (opens in a new tab) (CNIL) announced on October 29, 2026, that it fined Fnac Darty Participations et Services and Fnac Direct a combined 7 million euros. The enforcement action addresses the companies deploying mobile application trackers to collect user browsing history without prior consent. The collected data fueled targeted product recommendations and trained the recommendation algorithm of the retailer. The regulator also issued an injunction requiring the companies to demonstrate compliance within one month or face daily financial penalties. The decision highlights how data protection authorities enforce consent requirements on mobile applications and the algorithms they feed.
Who it applies to
The enforcement applies directly to Fnac Darty Participations et Services, which received a 6 million euro fine, and Fnac Direct, which received a 1 million euro fine. The decision concerns companies deploying application programming interfaces to track user activity within mobile environments. It applies to organizations that assign user identifiers to track activity, such as viewed products, within mobile applications.
The CNIL noted that its sanction reflects a "consistent and well-established body of case law" regarding trackers used for personalization and commercial targeting. The ruling demonstrates how trackers used for personalization and commercial targeting in mobile applications fall under Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act. Companies relying on mobile applications to gather training data for personalization engines fall within this regulatory scope.
The restricted committee justified the high penalty amount specifically because the application is used by a large number of people. This wide usage increased the scope of the processing and the number of individuals affected by the non-compliant tracking.
What it requires
Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act governs the rules for cookies and other tracking devices. It requires organizations to obtain prior consent from users before placing trackers. The law provides exemptions for trackers that are strictly necessary for the provision of an online communication service at the user's express request, or those intended solely to enable or facilitate electronic communication.
The CNIL determined that collecting browsing history to display personalized products and train recommendation algorithms does not qualify for these exemptions. The restricted committee found that the mobile application sent requests via an application programming interface to a third-party domain. These requests contained an identifier assigned to the user by the company and information about their activity, including specific products they had viewed.
The regulator ruled that these operations require prior consent. The data collection enabled the application to display complementary products, such as accessories, consumables, or related services. It also enabled the display of products with characteristics similar to the ones searched for by the user. Because these functions were not strictly necessary to deliver the core service requested by the user, they could not be implemented without prior consent.
Furthermore, the investigation revealed that the mobile application failed to recognize the choices of users who refused consent. The application continued to track their browsing activity despite their refusal. The decision establishes that using user activity data to train a recommendation algorithm is an operation requiring consent. The technical infrastructure must respect the user decision at every layer. A refusal to consent must halt the collection of browsing history for both targeted advertising and algorithm training.
The dates
The CNIL conducted its inspection of the mobile application in March 2024. This inspection followed a complaint lodged by the None Of Your Business association, a privacy advocacy group.
The restricted committee of the CNIL is the body responsible for issuing sanctions. This committee issued the formal deliberation and sanction on October 22, 2026.
The regulator made the decision public on October 29, 2026. The publication cites the seriousness of the breach, the scope of the processing, and the large number of individuals affected by the mobile application as the primary reasons for the public disclosure.
The companies have one month from the notification of the decision to demonstrate compliance. They must prove that their new tool enables them to obtain consent where necessary. If they fail to meet this deadline, the CNIL will impose a daily penalty of 10,000 euros for each day of delay.
What to check now
Organizations operating mobile applications can use this enforcement action to evaluate their own data collection practices.
- Map all tracking scripts and application programming interfaces embedded in mobile applications.
- Identify the specific data points collected by each tracker, including internal user identifiers and browsing history.
- Verify the exact business purpose of each tracker, separating baseline functionality from personalization and algorithm training.
- Confirm that trackers used for commercial targeting or algorithm training remain inactive until the user provides explicit consent.
- Test the application behavior when a user refuses consent to ensure no tracking requests are sent to internal or third-party domains.
- Review the data pipelines that feed internal recommendation algorithms to ensure they only ingest data from users who have consented to that specific processing purpose.
- Evaluate the consent management tools deployed within mobile environments to confirm they technically enforce user choices.
Sources
This article is general information, not legal advice. For your company's situation, talk to a qualified lawyer.
This article was written with AI and checked, sentence by sentence, against the sources linked above.